×
OUR SHOPIFY PACKAGES OUR PORTFOLIO FREE SEO AUDIT BUILD A SHOPIFY WEBSITE WHY SHOPIFY WHY SHOPIFY PLUS BLOG ABOUT US CALL US
01273569264
EMAIL US
info@whymatters.co.uk

Shopify Subscriptions

We implement, optimise, and grow Shopify subscription programmes that increase customer lifetime value and recurring revenue.

Shopify agency background 1 Shopify agency background 2 Shopify agency background 3 Shopify agency background 4
Shopify agency background 1 Shopify agency background 2 Shopify agency background 3 Shopify agency background 4

Why Add Subscriptions to Your Shopify Store?

Subscription revenue is the most predictable and commercially valuable income stream an ecommerce brand can build. Subscribers place nearly three times more orders than one-time shoppers, exhibit significantly higher lifetime value, and cost far less to retain than new customers cost to acquire.

As a certified Recharge partner, we help Shopify merchants implement subscription programmes that go beyond recurring billing. We design the subscriber experience, configure the customer portal, build the Klaviyo lifecycle flows that reduce churn, and continuously optimise every stage of the subscription journey to maximise retention and revenue.

For a complete guide to adding subscriptions to your Shopify store, see our article on how to add subscriptions to Shopify.

What We Deliver for Subscription Brands

Our subscription service covers the full lifecycle from initial setup to ongoing optimisation:

Subscription Platform Selection and Setup: We help you choose the right subscription app for your business and configure it correctly. For most growing brands, we recommend Recharge for its advanced customer portal, Klaviyo integration, and flexible subscription rules. For a detailed comparison of all options, see our guide to the best Shopify subscription apps.

Custom Subscriber Portal: We design and build a branded subscriber portal that gives your customers full control: pause, skip, swap products, change delivery dates, and update payment methods without contacting support. Merchants offering pause-before-cancel options see three out of four pausing subscribers eventually return.

Klaviyo Lifecycle Automation: As a Klaviyo partner, we build the email flows that drive subscription retention: welcome-to-subscription onboarding, upcoming renewal reminders, failed payment recovery, cancellation win-back, and milestone celebrations. These flows run automatically and generate the majority of subscription-related email revenue.

Product Page Optimisation: We optimise your product pages to maximise subscription uptake, including making subscriptions the default option where appropriate, clearly communicating the benefits of subscribing, and displaying social proof prominently.

Ongoing Subscription Optimisation: We monitor churn rate, customer lifetime value, subscription conversion rate, and cancellation reasons monthly. We make data-driven improvements to reduce churn and increase subscriber value continuously rather than treating the subscription programme as a completed project.

Tell us about your subscription project

Shopify Agency - SEO Agency

How Subscriptions Work on Shopify

Shopify now supports subscriptions natively through its checkout using "selling plans," which allow subscription apps to process recurring payments directly within Shopify's checkout rather than redirecting customers to a third-party checkout page. This means subscribers get the same high-converting Shopify checkout experience as one-time buyers.
Shopify handles the payment processing and checkout, while a subscription app (such as Recharge, Loop, or Appstle) handles the subscriber management dashboard, product configuration, customer portal, and analytics. You need both Shopify and a subscription app working together.
Shopify has also expanded its native subscription support with features like filtering customers by subscription status, setting distinct shipping rules for subscribers, and providing subscription-specific analytics within the Shopify admin.

Shopify Agency - SEO Agency
Shopify agency background 1 Shopify agency background 2 Shopify agency background 2 Shopify agency background 3 Shopify agency background 4

Which Products Work Best as Subscriptions?

Subscriptions work best for products customers naturally replenish: coffee, supplements, skincare, pet food, household essentials, and similar consumables. The key question is whether automatic delivery genuinely makes the customer's life easier. If it does, subscriptions will perform strongly. If the product is purchased infrequently or seasonally, a subscription model is unlikely to retain subscribers.
The most common subscription models for Shopify stores are replenishment subscriptions (the same product delivered on a regular schedule), curated subscription boxes (a selection of products that changes each delivery), and membership subscriptions (recurring fees in exchange for perks, discounts, or exclusive access).
For a detailed guide to choosing the right subscription model and avoiding the most common mistakes, see our article on the biggest Shopify subscription mistakes brands make.

Shopify Agency - SEO Agency

Shopify Subscription Specialists

How does Shopify work with subscriptions?

Knowing the exact amount of income flowing into your Shopify or Shopify Plus store each month ensures smooth operations. This information allows for efficient inventory management and sales projections and empowers you to plan for business expansion. Subscription data brings clarity to financial matters and sales figures, providing peace of mind and freeing up the capacity to focus on areas like customer support and order fulfilment to ensure a satisfied customer base.

Subscription options improve customer affordability and facilitate billing discounts. Businesses utilising a pay-per-product pricing model must continually invest in content, marketing, and sales to grow their client base and turnover. Integrating subscription orders into websites reduces the need for ad promotion, affiliate programs, YouTube, Instagram, or Pinterest campaigns to attract customers to your product page. The cost of acquiring customers is rising, a significant reason for the failure of startups and small businesses.

Shopify now offers native support for subscriptions directly within its platform. Customers will no longer be redirected to a non-Shopify checkout page to process their orders. This means that customers can seamlessly add subscription items to their cart and complete their purchase within the Shopify checkout. How does it work, you ask? Well, Shopify has introduced "selling plans," which are special pieces of code that inform the Shopify checkout that an item is a subscription and specifies the recurring payment interval and amount. But that's not all. Shopify does not handle the UI and dashboard for managing subscribers. Instead, it solely provides the capability to charge customers regularly using its native checkout. You'll need to choose a subscription app provider to set up subscription products, manage subscribers, and access subscription reporting. Check out our recommendations in the best Shopify subscription app section.

It's crucial to acknowledge that Shopify has significantly expanded its platform to better support subscriptions with tailored features. For instance, you can filter customer lists directly within Shopify based on subscription status. Additionally, you can establish distinct shipping rules for subscription customers, like offering free or customised shipping rates.

Regarding what's included with Shopify subscriptions, we've already discussed the role that Shopify plays, but it's essential to carefully assess your needs and the comprehensive offerings that come with Shopify and Shopify subscription apps

GET IN TOUCH

Subscription UI on Shopify

Most subscription apps include a default frontend widget allowing customers to choose between one-time purchase and subscription on the product page. However, the generic design rarely matches your brand. Our developers build custom subscription UI that reflects your brand identity and can be placed on product pages, collection pages, and the shopping cart. A well-designed subscription widget that clearly communicates the benefits of subscribing measurably increases subscription uptake.

Subscriber Portal

Giving customers control over their subscriptions is one of the most effective churn-reduction strategies available. The subscriber portal should allow customers to pause, skip, swap products, change delivery frequency, update payment methods, and add one-off products to their next delivery. We customise the Recharge portal to match your brand and ensure customers can manage every aspect of their subscription without contacting support.

Subscription Notifications

Your subscription app should send automated email and SMS notifications for upcoming deliveries, payment reminders, and subscription changes. We configure these through Klaviyo rather than the app's default notifications, giving you full control over the design, timing, and personalisation of every subscriber communication. For more on building effective email automation for subscription brands, see our Shopify email marketing guide.

Choosing the Right Subscription App

The right subscription platform depends on your business stage, subscriber volume, and the level of customer experience you want to deliver. We work primarily with Recharge as our recommended platform for growing and established subscription brands, but we help merchants evaluate all options based on their specific requirements.

For a comprehensive comparison of Recharge, Loop, Appstle, Seal, and Shopify Subscriptions, including pricing, features, and which is right for each business stage, see our detailed guide to the best Shopify subscription apps.

How to offer Build-A-Box with Shopify subscriptions

Build-a-box functionality allows customers to select their own combination of products within a subscription, giving them the power of choice while securing a recurring commitment. This model is particularly effective for food brands, beauty brands, and any merchant selling low-cost items that need to be bundled for commercial viability when selling online.

We implement build-a-box subscriptions through Recharge Bundles, creating a branded experience that integrates seamlessly with your store. Email us to discuss how build-a-box could work for your products.
See our work

What are the benefits of Adding Subscriptions to a Shopify store?

Subscriptions transform your revenue model from unpredictable one-time purchases to predictable recurring income. This predictability improves cash flow, simplifies inventory planning, and provides the data foundation for accurate growth forecasting.

Subscribers typically exhibit 67% higher lifetime value than one-time buyers. The cost of retaining a subscriber is a fraction of the cost of acquiring a new customer. And the data generated by subscription patterns, including churn rate, average subscription length, and product swap behaviour, gives you the insights needed to optimise both your subscription programme and your broader business strategy.

For a detailed analysis of how subscriptions fit within a broader retention strategy, see our guide on how to get Shopify repeat customers.

GET IN TOUCH

Improved Lifetime Value and AOV

Regular transactions are essential for gaining deep insights into your customers' behaviour, allowing you to continually enhance the personalised experience you offer. This creates a virtuous loop that keeps users and shoppers returning. Subscriptions, when implemented effectively, cultivate highly devoted recurring customers who spend 67% more than new ones, forming the cornerstone of customer lifetime value (LTV) and contributing significantly to a company's success.

Moreover, a subscription model uniquely positions you to drive more turnover from existing customers (Shopify Average Order Value). By maintaining continuous contact with your customers through subscriptions on Shopify, you are establishing a trusted relationship with them, making it easier to market additional products. Are you intrigued by the idea of adding subscriptions to Shopify? Reach out to us today for expert subscription management utilising APIs and integrations. When executed correctly, the opportunities for increasing subscription revenue are limitless.

GET IN TOUCH

Examples of Shopify Subscription models & how to choose your subscription model.

To set up your subscriptions, you must first select the products you plan to sell online and determine the type of subscription you want to offer. Your choice should be influenced by your product line, business strategy, and how you can attract customers to opt for a subscription through your store. Potential subscription types include smaller testing packs exclusively available to subscribers, refill subscriptions for when customers run out, content subscriptions for news or blogs, and memberships offering rewards and perks such as free delivery. Once you have a clear understanding of your offerings, you can make use of the advice in this article to launch your subscription business effectively on Shopify!

Product Bundles or Boxes

Product bundles or boxes offer a fantastic way to captivate customers with an exclusive collection of products all in one package. These offerings are regularly updated to maintain customer excitement over the assortment. For instance, a surprise box featuring various product selections allows customers to indulge in a broader range of your offerings - particularly advantageous for food or beauty brands! The appeal of product bundles lies in the element of surprise for customers, as they never know what they'll receive. Moreover, these bundles enable customers to sample a broader selection than if they were to make individual purchases. However, managing stock and continuously creating new bundles poses logistical challenges. Notable examples of successful product bundles include most typical wine/coffee/cheese rotating subscriptions, which enable customers to experience a new product each month.

Product refills

When it comes to replenishable products, a Shopify subscription is a no-brainer! With product refill subscriptions, you can ensure your customers always have a fresh supply of their favourite products. This is especially beneficial for consumable items like protein shakes, pet food, beauty products, and vitamins. Offering subscriptions can increase customer lifetime value, capitalise on upsell opportunities, and provide unparalleled convenience. While there may be concerns about margins, the benefits far outweigh any potential drawbacks.

Try before you buy

Offering a "try before you buy" option is an excellent way to encourage subscriptions. By providing customers with a discounted sample of your product that renews at regular intervals, you can keep them on a subscription plan. It's a win-win scenario: customers don't have to make a significant investment, and if your product is excellent, you'll gain a new subscriber.

Content Subscription

Creating incredible content, such as magazines, allows you to leverage a subscription model to generate recurring revenue. This not only builds a steady income stream for your content but also fosters brand loyalty as satisfied customers become strong advocates for your brand.

Memberships

Consider offering a membership for exclusive perks and rewards within your e-commerce brand. Take inspiration from successful examples like Amazon Prime, which provides members with benefits such as free next-day delivery, access to Prime Video, and more. Can you introduce compelling perks for a recurring membership fee to attract and retain customers? Create a loyal community of subscribers and show appreciation for their support. Imagine establishing a vibrant community like The Gin Club!

Subscriptions on Shopify

Shopify subscriptions equip businesses with the essential tools for effectively managing their subscription-based products and services. Offering a range of subscription plans, businesses can seamlessly customise their subscription offerings to precisely meet their unique requirements. Integration with various themes and templates ensures smooth customisation and branding. Moreover, subscription products can feature customer reviews and ratings, while Shopify Payments offers a streamlined method for managing charges and returns with reduced transaction fees compared to third-party gateways such as PayPal.

The Shopify app store offers apps like ReCharge for integrating subscriptions into a Shopify store. It also includes a range of third-party apps, such as Klaviyo and Gorgias, which help businesses efficiently manage their subscriptions. Utilise the subscription widget to easily link customers to subscription plans. Additionally, subscription rules should be set up to manage inventory forecasting and variant options effectively.
Why Matters is the ultimate Shopify subscription specialist. Our dedicated support team is always available to promptly address any changes or performance issues. We offer customised CSS and navigation options to perfectly match your business's language and style. Businesses can take advantage of a trial period to test subscription offerings before launching them to customers. Boost customer trust and confidence in your subscription services by adding a seal subscription widget to your website. Don't hesitate to contact our Shopify subscription team today to elevate your online store!

Shopify agency background 1 Shopify agency background 2 Shopify agency background 3 Shopify agency background 4

Seven Principles for a Successful Subscription Programme

Now that you know your options for creating subscriptions and implementing them on Shopify, let's review the proven industry practices.

  • 1) Make subscriptions the default option.
    Display the subscription option as the pre-selected choice on product pages. One-time purchase becomes the secondary option. This simple change measurably increases subscription uptake.

  • 2) Create a dedicated subscriptions page.
    A page in your main navigation explaining the benefits of subscribing gives casual visitors a reason to consider recurring purchase. Link to it from your product pages and footer.

  • 3) Show subscription options on collection pages.
    Do not limit the subscription widget to product pages only. Displaying subscription pricing and savings on collection pages creates additional touchpoints for conversion.

  • 4) Communicate benefits beyond the discount.
    Price savings are the most obvious benefit, but convenience, guaranteed availability, exclusive subscriber perks, and flexibility to pause or skip are equally persuasive for different customer segments.

  • 5) Make management easy and visible.
    Customers who can see that pausing, skipping, and cancelling are straightforward are more likely to subscribe in the first place. Transparency about flexibility reduces the perceived risk of commitment.

  • 6) Offer a first-order incentive.
    A discount on the first subscription delivery reduces the barrier to entry. Once a customer is subscribed, the convenience and value keep them retained beyond the initial incentive.

  • 7) Monitor and reduce churn continuously.
    Track your monthly churn rate, understand why subscribers cancel, and make targeted improvements. Small churn reductions compound into significant revenue gains over time.

Shopify Agency - SEO Agency

Technical Implementation

Shopify provides three core APIs that power subscription functionality:

  • Selling Plan API
    Allows subscription apps to define recurring purchase options (frequency, discount, delivery schedule) directly within Shopify's product and checkout system.

  • Subscription Contract API
    Manages the ongoing subscription relationship after the initial purchase, handling renewals, modifications, and cancellations.

  • Customer Payment Method API
    Securely stores payment methods so recurring charges can be processed without requiring the customer to re-enter payment details each cycle.

Our developers have deep experience with all three APIs and with Recharge's integration layer. Whether you need a straightforward subscription setup or a complex custom implementation, our team handles the technical complexity so you can focus on growing your subscriber base.

Shopify Agency - SEO Agency

When to Upgrade Your Subscription Platform

Many merchants start with Shopify's free native subscription app or a basic third-party solution. As your subscriber base grows, you may need more advanced features: a customisable customer portal, sophisticated Klaviyo integration, detailed subscription analytics, flexible subscription rules, and better churn prevention tools.
The right time to upgrade is when your current platform is limiting your ability to reduce churn, when subscribers are contacting support for tasks they should be able to handle themselves, or when you need deeper data to make informed decisions about your subscription programme.
We help merchants migrate between subscription platforms with minimal disruption to existing subscribers. Email us to discuss whether an upgrade would benefit your business.

Shopify Agency - SEO Agency